Reading the Embroidery Motifs of BaluchWomen's Clothing from the Perspective of Malinowski's Functionalism

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 MSc. Student in Textile and Fashion Design, Faculty of Art, Alzahra University, Tehran, Iran (Corresponding author)

2 Assistant Professor, Department of Textile and Fashion Design, Faculty of Art, Alzahra University, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Introduction
Baluchistan is located in the southeast of Iran and divided into two main regions: Sarhad in the north and Makoran in the south; the cities of Iranshahr and Saravan are situated between these two expanses. Baluch embroidery reflects the traditions, beliefs, and worldview of this ethnic group, representing the artistic heritage of Baluch women and girls. From an anthropological perspective, embroidery in Baluch culture is not merely a decorative art; rather, it is a cultural mechanism for the continuation of a collective identity as well as a response to the psychological and social needs of the community. Malinowski’s functionalist theory is precisely based on this foundation. It discusses how every cultural element within a social system has a specific role in maintaining balance, cohesion, and the reproduction of shared values. Embroidery can be seen as the tangible embodiment of Malinowski’s cultural functions that extend from basic biological needs to the deepest layers of the Baluch community’s spiritual cohesion. Beyond its decorative aspect, every motif is the concrete manifestation of the relationship between “institutions,” “needs,” and “functions.” Accordingly, every component of society has an effective function relative to the whole society, and its purpose is to meet human needs. Furthermore, according to Malinowski, every cultural phenomenon has two functional dimensions: a positive function that arises when the cultural element helps maintain the cohesion, stability, and balance of the social system and a negative function that is carried out when the same element causes tension, fragmentation, or disorder in the cultural structure. Identifying these two aspects enables an understanding of the internal dynamics of the culture and the interaction of its components with human needs.
Materials and Methods
The present study adopted a descriptive-analytic approach, gathering documentary data using electronic sources and note-taking tools. The sampling method was purposive; therefore, out of all the motifs present in Baluch embroidery, 40 motifs were selected. These motifs in terms of semantics, of frequency of use, and structural diversity (geometric, floral, animal, human) represent the most important cultural and aesthetic codes of the Baluch people. This selection was made based on distribution, persistent presence in prominent regional works, capacity for symbolization within Malinowski’s theoretical framework, and their role as a representative sample of the entire region and of the diverseBaluch embroidery styles. The objective of this research was to analyze the motifs of Baluch embroidery based on Malinowski’s functionalist theoretical framework to answer this question: how could the meanings of Baluch embroidery motifs be analyzed from the perspective of Malinowski’s functionalism at the three levels of primary, derivative, and spiritual-cohesive?
Results and Findings
Malinowski’s functionalism is based on three elements: whole, part, and relationship, with its ultimate goal as the preservation of the stability and continuity of the social system. In his view, humans are need-oriented beings and they create cultural mechanisms in order to meet their needs; these mechanisms are the institutions, each of which have a function in meeting biological, social, and psychological needs. In this context, Baluch embroidery was considered a cultural institution that could be analyzed at Malinowski’s three levels of needs. Level of primary needs explored how artistic motifs were symbolic responses to biological needs, protection, sustenance, and survival. Motifs such as Mērchok (small pepper) with the function of “spice, food enhancement, and hospitality solidarity” demonstrated the direct link between culture and biological needs for nutrition. Another example, Bahār (Spring), symbolizes abundance, freshness, and the hope for food production; in Malinowski’s functionalism, these motifs were instances of the cultural response to the biological needs for nutrition and reproduction. Level of derivative deeds was concerned with social institutions and human relationships. For example, the Borok motif (unopened flower bud), which expressed distance, frustration, and unfulfilled desire, had a function of emotional warning; it mirroreda culture that spoke of failure or separation through the language of symbols so as to control emotions and replace social violence. The Katārok motif (dandelion flower) andPād-e_Nonnok (baby’s foot) were also symbolic responses to social needs; the former announced friendship and the latter signified hope for the future and birth. These motifs referred to the continuity of generations and the reconstruction of family relationships. Their function is also social, not merely aesthetic. Level of spiritual-cohesive needs revolves around meanings, beliefs, and identities. The third level in Malinowski’s theory related to human psychological and spiritual needs; they mirrored how a culture in response to existential anxieties, fears, and questions created a system of symbols and beliefs. In Baluch embroidery, this level was manifested by motifs such as Bahār, Burrok, Hashās, Butteh, Penchpalang(Five Leopards), BālKabūtar (Pigeon Wing), Dentalū, Tā’ūs (Peacock), Cham Āhūg (Fawn’s Eye), Kallasiyahmar (Black Snake Head), Ādinak, Palivār, Rōch-Bar, and Delkash Dast Maras. The Penchpalang motif, implying power, unity, and cooperation, carries a function in maintaining the feeling of security and collective fortitude. In turn, it gives rise to moral and philosophical values. In the functional analysis of Baluch embroidery motifs, every motif not only carries meaning but also possesses a dual function: a positive function and a negative function. The positive function was carried out when the motif reinforced cultural cohesion and psychological and social stability, whereas the negative function expressed tension, anxiety, or cultural disharmony. For instance, the Mērchok motif, meaning small pepper, ultimately results in a positive function due to three principles of needs. In contrast, the Burrok motif (unripe blossom) reflects a failure to meet a biological need and is a sign of social tension; it, thus, has a negative function.
Conclusion
At the level of primary needs, the link between these motifs and biological and livelihood needs was evident. At the level of derivative needs, the motifs lent weight to ethical rules and collective cooperation; ultimately, at the level of spiritual cohesion, they provided collective tranquility. By highlighting three principles of need in the motifs and their positive functions, this analysis helps interpret the reality of how these symbols actively operate in the process of “cultural self-regulation.” This research intelligently focuses on extracting and explaining the positive function of these motifs because its central goal is to identify the symbolic mechanisms that make Baluch’s social system resilient against environmental fluctuations and internal tensions. Therefore, although the potential for negative or dual function exists, our analytical axis is to prove the constructive and stabilizing function of embroidery in the social structure of Baluch women. All findings are gathered in alignment with Malinowski’s views, and it is acknowledged that motifs in any society have a specific function, and their goal is the exaltation of the society.

Keywords


 References
Afshar Sistani, I. (1992). Baluchistan and its ancient civilization. Tehran: Ministry of Culture and Islamic Guidance ‎[In Persian].
Afshar Sistani, I. (1984). A look at Sistan and Baluchistan (The Land of Diligent Free People). Tehran: Homa Publications ‎[In Persian].
Afrough, M. (2009). Form and color in Balochiart. Book of the Month in Art, Issue 133, pp. 80 ‎[In Persian].
Alizadeh, S. (2015). Classification and introduction of Balochineedlework motifs and iconography. Faculty of Art, Soureh University, Tehran‎[In Persian].
Ansari, J. (2013). Introduction to Iranian folklore and ethnic groups. Tehran: SobhanNoor‎ [In Persian].
Beihaghi, H. (1986). Balochiart and culture. Honar Quarterly, (10), 444-471‎[In Persian].
Basal, A, Dadvar, A, Kateb, F, &Mounesisorkheh, M. (2023). A comparative study of human mythological clothing in wall paintings with syrianwomen in the Roman period (Malinowski’s Functionalist Approach). Quarterly Journal of Women in Culture and Art, 15(4), 595-627‎[In Persian].doi.org/10.22059/jis.2023.362004.1209
Fakouhi, N. (2016). History of anthropological thought and theories. Tehran: Ney Publications‎[In Persian].
Fereydoonzadeh, H, Keshavarz, G, & Yari, F. (2019). Aesthetics of urban cultural landscape in geographical and ethnic coordinates (Case study: Balochipeople). Scientific-Research Journal of Physical Development Planning, 4(2), 67-78‎[In Persian].doi.org/10.30473/psp.2019.6068
Ghasemi, M, Mahmoudi, S, & Mousavi Haji, S. (2013). Formal structure of natural Motifs in Balochiwomen’s needlework (with emphasis on Saravansamples). Scientific Research QuarterlyNegareh, (27), 61-73. ‎[In Persian].
Habibi Jouybari, H. (2014). A comparative study of the execution and motifs used in Balochi and Turkmen needlework art. Faculty of Art, Islamic Azad University, Art and Architecture Branch, Central Tehran, Tehran‎ [In Persian].
Heydari, R & Mahmoudi Alami, A. (2023). Investigating the role and design in the needlework art of Balochiwomen. Journal of Contemporary Research in Science and Research, 5(49), 75-87‎[In Persian].
Hosseini, M. (2020). A comparison of decorative motifs in Sistan’sembroidery with Baluchistan’s on clothing. Faculty of Art, University of Sistan and Baluchestan, Sistan and Baluchestan‎ [In Persian].
Jafari, M. (2019). Investigating the influence of Balochi women’s needlework motifs on the architecture of Baluchistan and the re-creation of motifs in contemporary architecture. Faculty of Art, University of Sistan and Baluchestan, Sistan and Baluchestan‎ [In Persian].
Javidsokhan, T, Dadvar, A, & Arab, Z. (2022). An examination and analysis of Australianaboriginal art with Malinowski’s functionalist approach. Quarterly Journal of Applied Arts, 2(2), 5-19‎[In Persian].doi.org/10.22075/AAJ.2022.24117.1109
Johnny, J. (2017). Notes on interdisciplinary perspectives of local colour identity. Journal of the International Colour Association, (19), 4–14.
Khamoushi, Z. (2008). The transformation in the use of decoration in Balochi and Turkmen needlework. Islamic Art, (9), 77–98. ‎[In Persian].
Khosravian, M &MahmoudiAlam, A. (2018). Needlework and its status in the clothing culture of the Balochipeople. International Conference on Civil Engineering, Architecture, and Urban Development Management - University of Tehran, 1-10‎. [In Persian].
Keshavarz, G, Aziz, M, &Mansouri, M. (2020). Geometric motifs in Balochineedlework. Scientific Biannual Register, 1(1), 123-135‎. [In Persian].doi.org/10.22077/rajshomar.2020.3392.1009
Keshavarz, G, Aziz, M, &Mansouri, M. (2019). Symbolic abstraction in the aesthetics of Baluchistan art (Case Study: Balochineedlework). BagheNazar Journal, 16(79), 5-14‎. [In Persian].
Keshavarz, G &Javadi, S. (2016). The Ratio of cultural sign in Balochineedlework. Journal of Eastern Art and Civilization, 4(13), 13-22. ‎[In Persian].
Mahmoudzehi, M. (2012). Rites, beliefs, and culture of the people of Baluchistan. Tehran: Abnoos‎[In Persian].
Malek, S. (2020). Identifying common motifs in Balochineedlework. Biannual Specialized Research Journal in Art and Specialized Sciences, 5(9), 69-76‎[In Persian].
Malinowski, B. (2004). The scientific theory of culture. Translated by ManouchehrFarhoomand. Tehran: Farhangh-e MoaserPublications‎ [In Persian].
Malinowski, B. (1948). Magic, Science and Religion and Other Essays. New York: The Free Press.
Morris, M. (1893). Decorative needlework. Kessinger Publishing, LLC, Whitefish, Montana, United.
Mounesisorkheh, M, Afrashteh, S, &Yousefi, Z (2022). Reading identity-building elements in the motifs of Turkmen rugs from the perspective of Malinowski’s functionalism. Fundamentals of Visual Arts Theory, (13), 140-155‎[In Persian].doi.org/10.22051/jtpva.2022.37853.1343
Mousavi Haji, S, Mahmoudi, S, &Ghasemi, M. (2014). Balochilocal clothing and its connection to national identity. National Studies Quarterly, 15(1), 180-200. ‎[In Persian].
Mirzaei, F &Mafitabar, A. (2023a). Analysis and classification of mirrors in Balochineedlework from the perspective of cultural beliefs. Quarterly Journal of Islamic Applied Arts, (7) 1, 127-143‎[In Persian].
Mirzaei, F &Mafitabar, A. (2023b). Thematic analysis and classification of motifs in Balochineedlework based on traditional art styles. Biannual Scientific Journal of Iranian Indigenous Knowledge, 9(19), 49-86‎[In Persian].doi.org/10.22054/qjik.2023.73115.1364
Namroudi, Z. (2016). Visual investigation of the pictorial and semantic roots of traditional Balochi art motifs and its comparative study with abstract painting. Art Faculty, Al-Zahra University, Tehran‎ [In Persian].
Narmashiri, A (2015). A study of geometric symbolic elements in Balochineedlework. Art Faculty, University of Sistan and Baluchestan, Sistan and Baluchestan‎ [In Persian].
Nazari, A, ZakeriKermani, I, &ShafieiSararoudi, M. (2014). A comparative study of motifs in Kalporganpottery with motifs in Balochineedlework. Quarterly Journal of Comparative Art Studies, 4(8), 31-47‎[In Persian].
Paziresh, M. (2019). Aesthetic evaluation of color and motifs in Balochiclothing for use in formal social Attire. Apadana Institute of Higher Education‎. [In Persian].
Rapoport, A. (1980). Using culture in housing design. University of Wisconsin. Milwaukee.
Sadeghi, H. (2015). Investigating Balochineedlework motifs and recreating them in interior decoration. Faculty of Art, Al-Zahra University, Tehran.‎[In Persian].
Saeedi, F, Ghasemi, M, &Mohammadi, S. (2023). A comparison of the art of Balochiembroidery in Iran and Pakistan in terms of patterning style, color scheme, and sewing technique. Journal of Fine Arts: Visual Arts, 28(3), 101-103‎[In Persian].doi.org/10.22059/jfava.2023.352679.667023
Shah bakhsh, S. (2005). Balochidecorative motifs. Book of the Month in Art, (89 & 90), 10-146‎[In Persian].
Shaari, N. (2015). Indigenous knowledge creativity in Batik cultural product based on Kansei. International Conference on Social Sciences and Humanities (ICSSH’15), Bali, Indonesia.
Siddiq, Muhammad &Kakar, Bashir. (2017). Hand embellished fabrics – An adoptable potential to empower household women in Baluchistan. Baluchistan Review, 34(1), 283-294.
TaheraZizi, M &Sheikhi, A. (2021). Typology and analysis of Balochi ethnic motifs in Sarhad and MakoranBalochi embroidery. RahpouyeHonar Journal: Visual Arts, 4(3), 59-74‎[In Persian].doi.org/10.22034/ra.2021.534803.1077
Tajvidi, Z. (2011). Recognition of Sistan and Baluchistan needlework motifs. Tehran: Yaran-e-Mehr‎ [In Persian].
Yaghoubi, H. (2014). Needlework of Balochiwomen’s clothing; pattern and color. Quarterly Journal of Iranian People’s Culture, (38-39), 52-78‎[In Persian].
Yarshater, E &Bolukbashi, A. (2004). clothing in the land of Iran. Translated by PeymanMatin. Tehran: Amirkabir‎ [In Persian].
Yavari, H &Sarkhoush, S. (2010). Familiarity with the traditional clothes and garments of the people of different regions of Iran. Tehran: SimayeDanesh, Azar‎ [In Persian].