نقاشی خودآگاه در عصر صفوی (نمونهٔ مطالعاتی: آثار صادقی‌بیگ کتابدار)‏‏

نوع مقاله : مقاله پژوهشی

نویسندگان

1 دانشجوی دکتری، گروه تاریخ تحلیلی و تطبیقی هنر اسلامی، دانشگاه هنر تهران، تهران، ایران

2 دانشیار، گروه نقاشی، دانشگاه هنر تهران، تهران، ایران (نویسنده مسئول)

چکیده

در تاریخ نقاشی ایرانی نقاط عطفی وجود دارد که در آن‌ها تحولات شایان توجهی در نقاشی ایرانی پدید آمده‌ و اغلب در سایهٔ تاریخ تحولات سیاسی، یا مطالعات توصیفی و زیبایی‌شناسانه  واکاوی شده‌اند. حال‌ آن‌که توجه به مفاهیم سوبژکتیو دخیل در خلق آثار هنری و رویکردهای میان‌رشته‌ای می‌تواند درک تحولات این بستر را به نحو بهتری فراهم کند. در این پژوهش که حول یکی از نقاط عطف نقاشی ایرانی یعنی دورهٔ صفوی انجام شده، با تمرکز بر مفهوم خودآگاهی سعی بر آن بود که فرضیه خودآگاهی به‌مثابه یکی از دلایل تحول نقاشی صفوی و شکل‌گیری ژانرهای تصویری نو در این دوره به‌عنوان یکی از ثمرات آن مورد آزمایش و بررسی قرار گیرد. به همین منظور صادقی‌بیگ کتابدار، یکی از پیشروترین هنرمندان دورهٔ صفوی، به‌عنوان نمونهٔ مطالعاتی این نوشتار انتخاب شد تا با راهبردی کیفی و با روش تحقیق توصیفی، تاریخ‌نگارانه و موردپژوهی مطالعه شود. پرسش این مطالعه عبارت بود از این‌که صادقی‌بیگ به‌عنوان یکی از متفاوت‌ترین و شاخص‌ترین هنرمندان دورهٔ صفوی در زمینهٔ خلق آثار بصری، خودآگاهی‌ خویش نسبت به کنش هنرمندانه‌اش را چگونه تبیین می‌کرد؟ که درنهایت به این نتیجه رهنمون شد که صادقی‌بیگ از راه‌های مختلفی چون تغییر سجع رقم، شیوهٔ ارائه آن، شرح‌نویسی بر آثار و درگیرکردن مخاطب با اثر، بهره‌گیری از سبک واقع‌گرایانه به خاطر تأثیرگذاری عمیقش در فرهنگ ایرانی، واردکردن موضوعات انسانی، فانی و آن‌چه در فرهنگ سنتی در سمت مقابل الهیات قرار می‌گرفت، و با کسب جایگاه حامی هنری که به دربار و بزرگان تعلق داشت، خودآگاهی‌ نسبت به هنر و هنرمندی‌ خویش را نشان می‌داد.

کلیدواژه‌ها


عنوان مقاله [English]

Self-aware Painting in the Safavid Era (A Case Study of Sadeqi Beiq Kitabdar's Works)

نویسندگان [English]

  • Fatemeh Mehrabi 1
  • Seyed Hasan Soltani 2
1 Ph.D. Candidate, Analytical and Comparative History of Islamic Art department, Art University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran
2 Associate Professor, Painting Department, Art University of Tehran, Tehran, Iran. (Corresponding Author)
چکیده [English]

Introduction
Sadiqi Beiq Kitabdar, as a prominent Persian artist from the tenth to eleventh centuries, holds a unique position in the annals of traditional Persian painting. Despite the extensive study done by Welch, exploration into his life and works has been scarce. Sadiqi's artistic brilliance was somewhat overshadowed by contemporaries such as Bihzad or Reza Abbasi, and compounded by his reputed sharp temper that deterred effusive praise from his peers. However, delving deeper into the narrative of his life reveals a fascinating tale of an unconventional Qizilbash warrior, who has ascended to the pinnacle of artistic mastery amidst the Safavid era's cultural ferment. Understanding Sadiqi's contributions necessitates a nuanced examination of his life's chronicle, set against the backdrop of Iran's socio-political milieu in the Safavid era. Welch's meticulous research has illuminated key facets of Sadiqi's existence, offering insights into his patronage dynamics and the evolving landscape of Persian artistry. This study endeavors to unravel Sadiqi's enigmatic persona while shedding light on his profound impact on the burgeoning self-awareness and artistic ethos of the Safavid epoch.
Research Method
This research adopts a qualitative strategy employing a descriptive, historiographical method. Focusing on the Safavid period, it examines the concept of self-awareness in Persian painting, with Sadiqi Beiq Kitabdar as the primary subject. The study analyzes Sadiqi's artistic expressions and signatures. To do so, it employs an interdisciplinary approach to understand his self-awareness and its impact on the Safavid painting evolution.
Research Findings
Sadiqi Beiq, renowned for his prowess as a painter, emerged equally as a self-aware and prolific writer. Through his literary works, particularly Majma' al-Khawas, Sadiqi revealed a keen awareness of his status and effectiveness across various domains. His writings were marked by directness, candid observations, and occasional criticisms, reflecting his self-assured persona. Sadiqi's interactions with contemporaries, artists, and peers underscored his self-awareness, evident in his nuanced assessments and critiques. Despite his sharp temperament, Sadiqi's writings offered insights into the social and cultural milieu of his time, positioning him and his contemporaries within the broader artistic landscape of the Safavid era.
In Majma' al-Khawas, Sadiqi showcased his discerning eye and critical attitude towards his contemporaries, sparing few from his candid evaluations. His commentary on poets and painters alike reflected his self-confidence and uncompromising nature. Notably, Sadiqi's writings depicted a selective acknowledgment of the talent, with few individuals receiving praise, often accompanied by subtle self-comparisons or references to his own accomplishments. His interactions with fellow artists revealed a complex blend of pride, confidence, and perhaps, a desire for recognition.
Sadiqi's self-awareness extended beyond his literary works to his treatises on painting such as Qanun al-Sovar. In this technical treatise, he positioned himself as an authority, advocating naturalism and emphasizing the significance of imbuing paintings with meanings. Sadiqi's self-appointed role, as a guide in the realm of Persian painting, reflected his aspiration for lasting recognition and influence. Moreover, his writings suggested a deep-seated desire for artistic mastery and innovation, evident in his quest to explore the meaning behind painting. Through his poems and treatises, Sadiqi crafted a narrative of self-aggrandizement, portraying him as a polymath of an unparalleled talent. Despite occasional critiques from contemporaries like Iskandar Beiq Turkman, who had questioned his literary prowess, Sadiqi's writings exuded confidence and self-assurance. His self-perception, as a multifaceted artist who was adept in both poetry and painting, underscored his ambition and self-awareness. Contemporary accounts offered further insights into Sadiqi's self-aware persona. Mirza Taher Nasrabadi's anecdote depicted Sadiqi's assertiveness and awareness of his artistic value as he swiftly dismissed praise in favor of material recognition. Similarly, Ohadi-e Balyani and Valeh Esfahani's descriptions highlighted Sadiqi's reputation for haughtiness and conceit, which aligned with his strong sense of self-awareness.
Overall, Sadiqi Beiq emerged as a multifaceted figure, whose writings and interactions reflected a nuanced understanding of his own abilities and place within the artistic community. His self-awareness, even though perceived as arrogance in some cases, was integral to his identity as an artist striving for recognition and mastery in the vibrant cultural milieu of Safavid Iran.
Conclusion
The study has delves into the transformative process, whereby artists' self-awareness shaped the trajectory of modern Persian painting with a focus on the influential figure of Sadiqi Beiq during the Safavid era. Through an examination of Sadiqi's self-awareness in his artistic endeavors, the study has elucidated his pivotal role in fostering a movement of artist self-awareness within this period. Sadiqi's extensive body of works, encompassing both paintings and writings, has underscored his acute awareness of his impact and status as an artist. His writings, whether authored by him or about him, revealed a nuanced understanding of his influence, which he strategically leverages when necessary. Moreover, while Sadiqi's critiques of others were at times harsh, his deliberate concealment of opinions regarding certain individuals suggested a calculated control over his behavior, indicative of his self-awareness.
The study contends that Sadiqi's self-awareness and intelligence were instrumental in shaping contemporary modern painting art. Traditionally, Persian painting revolved around narrative-driven illustrations, characterized by a plethora of motifs and a rational, imaginative atmosphere. However, amidst religious reforms in Iran, the exodus of painters from the court led to a democratization of art patronage, resulting in a proliferation of painting genres and styles. This transition from elaborate, narrative-driven illustrations to single-page paintings marked a shift towards audience’s deeper engagement and reflection.
In this period of artistic flux, Sadiqi and his contemporaries played a pivotal role in shaping modern Persian painting. Sadiqi's treatise on painting emphasized the importance of capturing both form and meaning and advocated a closer resemblance to nature in artworks. His artistic evolution mirrored this ethos as his works progressively embraced natural elements and techniques, such as perspective and shading, borrowed from the Western art. Notably, Sadiqi's reconfiguration of traditional painting formats and incorporation of natural elements facilitated a closer alignment between art and reality and elevated Persian painting to the new heights of realism and human-centric expression.
In conclusion, the study posits Sadiqi Beg Mosavver as a central figure in the emergence of modern Persian painting. His self-awareness and artistic innovations served as catalysts for transformative change within the artistic landscape of the Safavid era. Through his visionary approach to painting and his profound understanding of artistic expression, Sadiqi left an indelible mark on the Persian art, ushering in an era characterized by heightened emotional resonance, narrative depth, and humanistic sensibility.

کلیدواژه‌ها [English]

  • Persian painting
  • Safavid painting
  • self-awareness
  • Sadeqi Beiq Kitabdar
 
آژند، یعقوب. (138۵). مکتب نگارگری اصفهان. تهران: موسسه تألیف، ترجمه و نشر آثار هنری «متن».
-----. (1392). نگارگری ایران (ج. 2). تهران: سمت.
اسکندربیگ ترکمان. (13۵0). تاریخ عالم‌آرای عباسی (ج. 1). تهران: امیرکبیر.
افشار، ایرج. (1382). رسائل: حظیات (نگارش صادقی‌بیگ افشار). آینه میراث، ش. ۲۳، 1۴۵-1۸۴.
حر عاملی، محمدبن حسن. (138۴). وسائل الشیعه (ج. 3). تهران: مکتبه الإسلامیه.
خزایی، محمد. (1398). هنر طراحی ایرانی اسلامی. تهران: سمت.
زند، مازیار. (1398). شاخصه‌های مؤثر در انتقال پیام تصویری با تأکید بر فرهنگ دیداری (رساله دکتری منتشرنشده). دانشکده علوم نظری و مطالعات عالی هنر، دانشگاه هنر تهران، ایران.
صادق‌پور، میثم. (1399). تحلیل مناسبات قدرت در نقاشی صفوی سده دهم هجری ‏(رساله دکتری منتشرنشده). ‏ دانشکده هنرهای صناعی، دانشگاه هنر اسلامی تبریز، ایران.
فتوحی رودمعجنی، محمود. (139۵). صدسال عشق مجازی: مکتب و طرز واسوخت در شعر فارسی قرن دهم. تهران: سخن.
قاضی میراحمد منشی قمی. (13۵2). گلستان هنر. تهران: بنیاد فرهنگ ایران.
میچل، ویلیام. (1399). فراتصویرها. ترجمهٔ صالح نجفی، حرفه هنرمند، ش. ۷۵، 2-17.
واعظ کاشفی، ملاحسین. (1002 ه.ق). انوار سهیلی. محفوظ در موزه آقاخان، شماره بازیابی: A.N. AKM289. برگرفته از: https://www.agakhanmuseum.org/collection/artifact
Canby, Sh. (2002). The golden age of Persian art: 1501-1722. London: British Museum.
Gandjei, T. (1975). Notes of the Life and Work of Sadiqi: A Poet and Painter of Safavid Times. Der Islam; Zeitschrift für Geschichte und Kultur des Islamischen Orients, No. 52, 112-118.
Mitchell, W.  J. T. (1994). Picture Theory: Essays on Verbal and Visual Representation. University of Chicago Press.
Nöth, W. (2007). Metapictures and Self-Referential Pictures. Published by De Gruyter Mouton.
Pericolo, L. (2015). What is Metapainting? The Self-Aware Image twenty years later. In V. I. Stoichita. The Self-Aware Image: an Insight into Early Modern Metapainting (Studies in Baroque Art) (Harvey Miller Studies in Baroque Art) (pp. 11-31). Brepols Publishers.
Roxburgh, D. (2000). Kamal Al-Din Bihzad and Authorship in Persianate Painting. Muqarnas, No. 17, 119-146.
Skelton, R. (2000). Ghiyath al-Din ‘Ali-yi Naqshband and an Episode in the Life of Sadiqi Beg. In R. Hillenbrand (Ed.). Persian Painting from the Mongols to the Qajars (pp. 249– 263). London: ‎I. B. Tauris.
Stchoukine, I. (1964). Les Peintures des Manuscrits de Shah 'Abbas 1er à la Fin des Safavis. Paris: Librarie Orientaliste Paul Geuthner.
Welch, A. (1976). Artists for the Shah. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.
Stoichita, V.  I. (2015). The Self-Aware Image an Insight into Early Modern Metapainting. Harvey Miller Publishers.
منابع اینترنتی
URL1: http://www.bl.uk/manuscripts/Viewer.aspx?ref=or_12985_f045v
URL2: https://harvardartmuseums.org/collections/object/217206?position=0
URL3: https://www.britishmuseum.org/collection/object/W_1948-1211-0-8
URL4: https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/btv1b84322162/f100.item
URL5: https://viewer.cbl.ie/viewer/image/Per_260_8/2/LOG_0000/
URL6:https://www.thedigitalwalters.org/Data/WaltersManuscripts/W668/data/W.668/sap/W668_000141_sap.jpg
URL7: https://art.thewalters.org/detail/83862/man-on-a-donkey/
URL8: https://collections.louvre.fr/en/ark:/53355/cl010329522
References
Afshar, I. (2003). Resalat: Haziyat (written by Sadiq Bey Afshar). Ayeneh-e Miras, 2, 145-184. [In Persian]
Azhand, Y. (2006). The School of Calligraphy in Isfahan. Tehran: Matn, Institute for Compilation, Translation, and Publication of Artworks. [In Persian]
-----. (2013). Persian Painting (Vol. 2). Tehran: Samt. [In Persian]
Canby, Sh. (2002). The golden age of Persian art: 1501-1722. London: British Museum.
Eskandar beg Turkamaan. (1971). History of Abbasid Intellectuals (Vol. 1). Tehran: Amir Kabir.
Fotouhi Roodmajani, M. (2016). One Hundred Years of Virtual Love: School and Method of Burning in Persian Poetry of the Tenth Century. Tehran: Sokhan. [In Persian]
Gandjei, T. (1975). Notes of the Life and Work of Sadiqi: A Poet and Painter of Safavid Times. Der Islam; Zeitschrift für Geschichte und Kultur des Islamischen Orients, No. 52, 112-118.
Hor Ameli, M. (2005). Vasael of the Shia (Vol. 3). Tehran: Maktabat al-Islamiyah. [In Arabic]
Khazaei, M. (2019). Islamic Persian Drawing Art. Tehran: Samt. [In Persian]
Mitchell, W.  J. T. (1994). Picture Theory: Essays on Verbal and Visual Representation. University of Chicago Press.
Mitchell, W. (2020). Metapicture. Translated by Saleh Najafi, Art Professional, 75, 2-17. [In Persian]
Nöth, W. (2007). Metapictures and Self-Referential Pictures. Published by De Gruyter Mouton.
Pericolo, L. (2015). What is Metapainting? The Self-Aware Image twenty years later. In V. I. Stoichita. The Self-Aware Image: an Insight into Early Modern Metapainting (Studies in Baroque Art) (Harvey Miller Studies in Baroque Art) (pp. 11-31). Brepols Publishers.
Qazi Mir Ahmad Manshi Qomi. (1973). The Rose Garden of Art. Tehran: Iran Cultural Foundation. [In Persian]
Roxburgh, D. (2000). Kamal Al-Din Bihzad and Authorship in Persianate Painting. Muqarnas, No. 17, 119-146.
Sadeghpour, M. (2020). Analysis of Power Relations in Safavid Painting of the Tenth Hijri Century (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Faculty of Industrial Arts, Tabriz Islamic Art University, Iran. [In Persian]
Skelton, R. (2000). Ghiyath al-Din ‘Ali-yi Naqshband and an Episode in the Life of Sadiqi Beg. In R. Hillenbrand (Ed.). Persian Painting from the Mongols to the Qajars (pp. 249– 263). London: ‎I. B. Tauris.
Stchoukine, I. (1964). Les Peintures des Manuscrits de Shah 'Abbas 1er à la Fin des Safavis. Paris: Librarie Orientaliste Paul Geuthner.
Stoichita, V.  I. (2015). The Self-Aware Image an Insight into Early Modern Metapainting. Harvey Miller Publishers.
Va'ez Kashfi, M. H. (1584). Anwar Sohaili. Preserved at the Aga Khan Museum, Retrieval Number: A.N. AKM289. Retrieved from:  https://www.agakhanmuseum.org/collection/artifact   [In Persian]
Welch, A. (1976). Artists for the Shah. New Haven and London: Yale University Press.
Zand, M. (2019). Effective Factors in Visual Communication with Emphasis on Visual Culture (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). Faculty of Theoretical Sciences and Advanced Studies in Art, Tehran University of Art, Iran. [In Persian]